Receivers, Separates, and Sound Options
Depending on budget and desire for certain components, buyers have numerous choices on the audio side of home theater entertainment. In the beginning, especially with a low budget in hand, it’s better to start off simply.
Receiver Or Separates: The Oldest Question In The Book
This is one of the oldest questions about home theater audio. Consumers read reviews and use their own experience and preferences on which products to buy. Some people prefer Yamaha, while others prefer Denon. Others may prefer higher-priced separate components and skip the big name brand companies. There are supporters on each side of the issue and the battle won’t soon die down.
A receiver can be the core of an audio system, offering the ability not only to decode digital audio formats found on DVD and Blu-ray disc but can be used as a radio and can send video signals to a high definition display. The advantages of using a receiver lie inconvenience, price, and (usually) easy use, plus the ability to decode the current sound formats. They can be purchased locally or online for reasonable prices. A receiver can be a fine choice in starting a new home theater system, or in upgrading a current one. Keep in mind that audio signals through a receiver that digitizes are never sounded good.
Some audiophiles may prefer using components to separate traditional two-channel music from the multichannel sound. Separates can, depending on the company that makes them, sound superior on two-channel recordings. The idea here is to separate analog sources like an LP or analog cables from a CD player or computer (run via USB to an outboard digital-to-analog converter) into a pre-amplifier. There is also the option to add a more powerful amplifier to the system. Audiophiles still can still use a receiver or dedicated surround sound processor for decoding DVD and Blu-ray discs as long as the receiver has a pre-out jack.
Here’s a breakdown on the most common current sound formats. Each format can vary in how many channels they can play back, from 1.0 (mono) to 7.1 (seven channels, plus a subwoofer track).
·Uncompressed PCM (pulse code modulation)
·DTS (Digital Theater Systems)
·Uncompressed PCM (pulse modulation)
·DTS-HD Master Audio
There’s been debate over which sound format is best. Each has its merits. What are the differences in these sound formats?
Uncompressed PCM sound is the most accurate method in hearing a movie soundtrack. Sony, Disney, and Warner Bros. home video released many of their early Blu-ray discs in this format. It’s essentially the same as getting sound from the original studio mix. But in the last year, all of the studios have been releasing their Blu-ray discs in either Dolby TrueHD and/or DTS-HD Master Audio. PCM tracks found on DVD are usually featured on concert videos. PCM can sound superior to any of the compressed sound formats if they’re mastered properly. PCM can also sound cleaner and offer better sound staging than the compressed audio formats.
Dolby Or DTS
Dolby and DTS compress the sound. In other words, those formats take out what the human ear apparently can’t hear. This is very similar to how MP3 files work. To some, there is no difference in PCM versus any of the compressed sound formats. To others, there is a difference. Compressed sound takes away the clarity and dynamic sound quality found on many movie soundtracks.
Dolby Digital is perfectly adequate for DVD, but it does have some shortcomings. The audio is highly compressed, and depending on the soundtrack on how it was mixed and then presented on DVD, can sound just ok or very good. Audio playback can range from a paltry 192kbps (kilobytes per second) to 448kbps.
DTS is an alternative, and to some, superior to Dolby Digital. This format still compresses audio, but not as severely as Dolby Digital. The sound can be louder and clearer in some cases, but not all.
Dolby TrueHD or DTS-HD Master Audio
On Blu-ray, Dolby TrueHD and DTS-HD Master Audio have the ability to present highly improved sound quality over DVD. Each format runs at a high megabyte per second rate, letting the sound breathe and not sound trapped or bottled up.
These formats are advertised as being identical to the original sound mix, but that can be debatable in some instances. With time-and-phase correct speakers, like those from Vandersteen or Thiel, some of these soundtracks may sound a bit compressed. On other speakers, they may not. Both formats, regardless, are a huge improvement over the audio featured on DVD.
Depending on the original mix, or how the DVD/Blu-ray discs were mastered, not all soundtracks will sound excellent. Some titles may have been mastered at a lower volume, or some older titles may sound a bit distorted due to their original recordings. Some titles may have been recorded poorly, to begin with. Just be aware that not all movies will blast everyone out of their chairs, and weren’t meant to.